How the heck does Caitlin Flanagan manage to get pretty much everyone irritated with her, some to the point of threatening to challenge her to a duel? Okay, I made that up, but it seems that bad to me, anyway. I was all set to give her book To Hell With All That: Loving and Loathing Our Inner Housewife a pass on judgment, particularly because so many reviewers were being, well--a little harsh. You know, the fact that Flanagan had a nanny and still has a housekeeper and does precious little in the way of cooking and cleaning should not disqualify her from writing about her mixed feelings on housekeeping and everyday life with kids, I figured. Before I'd read more than half of the book, I'd gone so far as to write this in the little notebook I carry everywhere with me:
I am not inclined to write a comprehensive review of To Hell With All That, partly because others have already done so, and partly because I don't feel strongly about this book, or Flanagan, one way or the other.
Now that I've finished the book, it's still true that I'm not going to do a comprehensive review. However, that lack of opinion "one way or the other" pretty much went out the window when I read Flanagan's mention of attachment parenting:
I understood the rationale behind Dr. Sears's weird recommendation that we should all bunk down in the same bed like dingoes in a den, and I knew from La Leche League (a group whose fixation on other women's breasts I came to regard as sexually suspect) that a breastfed baby would be superior in every possible way to a bottle-fed one. (121)
I'm all for tongue-in-cheek observations, but really: bunking down in the same bed "like dingoes in a den"? How about like humans have been doing, safely, for thousands of years? And what's that about LLL's supposed fixation on human breasts that Flanagan found sexually-suspect? Them's fighting words. I suppose Flanagan must accordingly believe that all podiatrists have foot fetishes and all gynecologists are total perverts; I could go on. Does she even see the ridiculousness of her assertion, which she backs up in absolutely no way at all? Gotta say, I was involved with La Leche League at different levels for a number of years, and I never found anyone, Leader or group mom, who seemed even remotely sexually-fascinated by breasts. I can feel my blood pressure going up as I'm writing this, so I'm just going to leave it at that.
I do like that Flanagan can and does poke fun at herself and some of the choices she and others of her elevated social class have made. So I'll move on, to a couple of quotes from the book that I found thoughtful and maybe less-threatening:
The current upper-middle-class practice of outsourcing even the most intimate tasks may free up valuable time for an important deposition, but it by no means raises the caliber of one's home life. (201)
That's rich, from someone who has a maid and a once-a-week home organizer (!), which leads to the next quotation:
For many women, myself included, thrashing through the flotsam of a household in the cheerful company of a professional organizer provides the illusion that we are getting control of the lives we are living.
Pretty interesting thought, that.
And here's something that will really thrill Husband. In one of the better chapters, the one entitled "Housewife Confidential," Flanagan talks about famous "housewife writers" of the past, including Erma Bombeck and Peg Bracken. I remember reading Bombeck as a child (a fairly precocious literature choice that doesn't make much sense to me looking back on it--but hey, those books are funny!). I also remember Peg Bracken's books The I Hate to Cook Book and the The I Hate to Housekeep Book, complete with illustrations by Hilary Knight, of Eloise fame. I think my family owned the cookbook, as did many, many other American households. What Husband will appreciate is that while reading about these books, I felt the pull of nostalgia so strongly that I now think I should start a collection of cool vintage housekeeping books. Time for a new bookshelf. I plan to start with Bracken's books (loads of them on ebay, by the way).
Well, this wasn't exactly the"30-Second Review" I'd planned. I'll stop now. I think my blood pressure is still a bit high. Happy thoughts, deep breaths...happy thoughts, deep breaths...